The Giver — Chapter 6

Narration Prompt

Reconstruct the chapter as a single civic argument Lois Lowry is building toward the Ceremony of Twelve: the opening scene of Mother tying Lily's hair ribbons establishes the community's insistence on the neatness of its visible markers; the family's ride to the Auditorium passes through an anonymous throng in which Jonas stows his bicycle; Father's plea-won reprieve for Gabriel is paired with the family pledge not to become attached; the graded Ceremonies (back-buttoned jackets, the Seven's first front-buttoned jacket, Lily's Eight jacket with pockets, the Nines' bicycles, the Tens' haircuts, the Elevens' calculators) are then narrated as a machine of staged maturity; the Murmur-of-Replacement Ceremony for the new Caleb and the telling silence around the new Roberto expose the community's ration of grief; Fritz's small transgressions and his parents' dread surface the cost of permanent visibility; Asher's Sanitation Laborer rumor and the Matching of Spouses procedure function as the community's tolerances for fear and for chosen love; and the closing signal — arriving 'as if in answer' to Jonas's unspoken wish — reveals the community's ambient anticipation of its citizens' interiors.

Discussion Questions

1. Lois Lowry builds the chapter as a chained inventory of visible markers — Lily's ribbons, back-buttoned jackets for the Fours through Sixes, the Seven's front-buttoned jacket, Lily's new Eight jacket with pockets, the Nines' bicycles, the Tens' haircuts, the Elevens' calculators. Consider the implicit philosophical argument Lois Lowry is pressing through this inventory about the relationship between the civic installation of a symbol and the interior reality that symbol is supposed to track; articulate whether Lois Lowry believes a well-engineered community of this kind is producing mature citizens or is producing a highly legible surface and calling that surface the citizen.
2. The Murmur-of-Replacement Ceremony restores the name Caleb to the community's shared consciousness after the lost Four drowned in the river, while the new Roberto is named in silence because Roberto the Old was released, and the narration glosses this as 'Release is not the same as Loss.' Consider what is at stake, ethically and politically, in a community that has engineered a sharp administrative distinction between losses it did not cause and losses its own procedures produced; consider whether public grief can remain grief when its permissible objects are rationed by the body that causes the releases.

+ 2 more questions in the complete study guide