The Giver — Chapter 21

Narration Prompt

Before leading the discussion, summarize chapter twenty-one as a rupture in the plan established in chapter twenty: the two-week cover period is collapsed by Gabriel's scheduled release, and Jonas executes an unrehearsed flight carrying the newchild. Note for the group that the chapter's architecture is two-part — a short domestic scene at the evening meal, and a longer narration of the escape in which Jonas and Gabriel are repeatedly called 'the fugitives.' Call attention to the passages where Jonas transmits memories to Gabriel (the hammock, the snow) and the passage where Jonas notices the memories becoming 'more shallow, a little weaker than they had been.'

Discussion Questions

1. Lowry compresses fourteen days of planned escape into a single unplanned night. Hannah Arendt, writing on the banality of evil, argued that totalitarian systems disable the capacity for moral action by separating decision from execution — one plans in meetings and another performs in hallways. In chapter twenty-one, Lowry does the opposite: Jonas decides and executes in the same hours. Discuss whether the compression makes Jonas's act more morally legible than the two-week version would have been, or whether it sacrifices a demonstration of moral character-formation the novel needs. Consider the exchange at the evening meal — where Father announces Gabriel's release — and evaluate whether the sudden flight is the plan's failure or its refinement.
2. The hammock-under-palm-trees memory Jonas transmits to Gabriel is a memory Jonas himself received from The Giver and never lived. The snow-memories Jonas deploys against the heat-seeking planes work the same way. Discuss what Lowry is claiming about the ownership and transferability of received experience. Is Jonas borrowing, owning, or practicing when he deploys these memories? Consider Giorgio Agamben's distinction in 'Means Without End' between memory as archive (stored record) and memory as potency (active capability), and ask whether the chapter's events require one theory or the other.

+ 2 more questions in the complete study guide