Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
This is chosen because it is the exact sentence on which the entire novel's plot hinges — the moment Elya Yelnats breaks the promise that will curse his family for four generations. Sachar places the memory AFTER the ship has cleared the harbor, not before, because 'too late' is a much heavier kind of regret than regret you can still act on. Notice that Elya himself does NOT believe in the curse — he thinks it is 'nonsense' — and yet he still feels terrible, which tells us his guilt comes from hurting Madame Zeroni, not from fearing magic. This is the sentence every later chapter of the book is secretly attached to, and copying it carefully is the way to feel the weight of a broken promise settling in.
It wasn't until the ship had cleared the harbor and was heading out across the Atlantic that he suddenly remembered his promise to carry Madame Zeroni up the mountain. He felt terrible. He wasn't afra...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
In five to six sentences, retell Chapter 7's two stories at once. Say what Stanley does all day under the hot sun, how his hands change, and what he does at the very end of the chapter. Then say what happens to Elya — the pig, the promise, Myra's number-guessing, the ship to America, the broken promise, and Sarah Miller. Finish by connecting the two stories: why Sarah names her son Stanley and what song she sings to him.
Discussion Questions
- Sachar makes Elya remember his broken promise only after the ship has left the harbor — not while Elya is still in the village. What does this choice show us about how Sachar wants us to feel about Elya? Why is 'too late' a heavier kind of regret than regret a person can still fix?
- Madame Zeroni says Elya's family will be 'doomed for all of eternity' if he breaks his promise — but Elya does not even believe in the curse; he calls it 'nonsense.' What does it mean that the curse works even though the person it was placed on does not believe it? What is Sachar saying about how promises and curses are connected in this family?
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary Builder
Item 1
A firm agreement to do something for another person; Elya makes this to Madame Zeroni about carrying her up the mountain, and breaking it is the one hinge on which the whole Yelnats family story turns.
Item 2
A protected stretch of water where ships anchor before heading out to sea; Elya's ship clears this one on the way to the Atlantic, and it is the moment after the ship leaves this that Elya remembers his broken promise.
Item 3
The ocean that separates Europe from the Americas; Elya crosses it as a deck hand on the ship that takes him from Latvia to America, and it is the water he is heading across when he realizes his promise is already behind him.
+ 5 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 5 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free