Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
This is the chapter's pivot — the moment a counselor tells a wrongly convicted boy that he has 'made some bad mistakes' and the boy agrees to the lie in silence. The passage is doing two pieces of work at once. First, it captures the precise register of therapeutic-sounding institutional speech (respect, mistakes, don't mean you're a bad kid — all the vocabulary of a well-trained counselor). Second, it shows Stanley performing the response the institution wants. His internal reasoning ('It seemed pointless ... everyone probably said that ... didn't want ... to think he had a bad attitude') is a ten-word portrait of how quickly institutional speech teaches its captives to silence themselves. Stanley renames Pendanski 'Pen-dance-key' in his head — a small, silent mockery — the same second he accepts being called a kid who 'made some bad mistakes.'
"I want you to know, Stanley, that I respect you," Mr. Pendanski said. "I understand you've made some bad mistakes in your life. Otherwise you wouldn't be here. But everyone makes mistakes. You may ha...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Retell Chapter 5 in five or six sentences. Include Stanley's arrival at D tent, his first exchange with Mr. Pendanski, the introduction of Rex, Alan, José, Theodore, Ricky, and Zero (and their nicknames), Mr. Pendanski's remark that Zero has 'nothing inside his head,' X-Ray's 'I can see inside you, Mom,' and Armpit's double act (throwing Stanley to the ground and then telling him where to find water).
Discussion Questions
- Mr. Sir (Chapter 4) delivers the camp's physical rules; Mr. Pendanski (Chapter 5) delivers the camp's psychological rules. What does each counselor strip from Stanley, and why does Sachar pair them in consecutive chapters?
- Mr. Pendanski insists on calling the boys 'Rex,' 'Alan,' 'Theodore,' so society will 'recognize them' when they return. X-Ray answers with 'I can see inside you, Mom. You've got a big fat heart.' Whose theory of naming is more accurate to the reality of Camp Green Lake, and what does each theory assume about who the boys really are?
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary Builder
Item 1
To recognize and honor someone's worth as a person — Mr. Pendanski claims to do this for Stanley in his opening speech.
Item 2
To grasp the meaning, situation, or inner reality of something or someone — Mr. Pendanski claims this about Stanley's 'mistakes,' but the reader knows he is wrong.
Item 3
Under any other circumstances; if the stated condition were not true — Mr. Pendanski argues that Stanley must be guilty because 'otherwise' he would not be at the camp.
+ 5 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 6 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free