Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
This is one of the quietest but most important turning points in Stanley's search. The line 'the fact that there was something in the middle of all this nothing made it hard for him to pass up' is Sachar's clearest statement of an existential truth: in emptiness, any presence — even a doubted, possibly meaningless presence — becomes a reason to keep going. Heidegger's ontology of 'somethingness against the horizon of nothing' is here rendered in a children's sentence. Then Sachar deflates the philosophy into comedy — a boat in the desert — and reflates it with the historical recognition: 'this was once a lake.' The passage holds metaphysics, comedy, and elegy in one paragraph.
He changed directions. He doubted it was anything, but the fact that there was something in the middle of all this nothing made it hard for him to pass up. He decided to make the object his halfway po...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Summarize Chapter 34 with attention to its rhythm of false hopes and real discoveries. Trace Stanley's deliberation: the feeling of pointlessness; the mirage that hurries away from him; the first sight of Big Thumb (shaped like a fist with thumb sticking up) and its paradoxical 'encouragement'; the decision to aim for a mysterious reachable object instead of the impossible mountain; the discovery that the object is the overturned wreck of a boat called 'Mary Lou'; and the final moment when a dark hand and an orange sleeve emerge from under the boat.
Discussion Questions
- Consider Sachar's description of the mirage: 'The pool hurried away from him, moving as he moved, stopping when he stopped.' The scientific explanation (heat-bent light) follows as a flat sentence, but Sachar has already rendered the mirage as an agent with a will. What is the effect of personifying an optical illusion, and how does this craft choice enact one of the novel's larger arguments about how perception, desire, and landscape conspire?
- Big Thumb 'seemed to encourage' Stanley by 'giving him the thumbs-up sign.' The encouragement is not really coming from the mountain. Analyze this passage as an instance of what psychologists call apophenia — the human tendency to see patterns and intentions in random features of the environment. Is Sachar affirming or critiquing this tendency? What does it suggest about the relationship between hope and self-deception?
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary Builder
Item 1
Felt uncertain about whether something was true, possible, or worthwhile; questioned a proposition without rejecting it outright.
Item 2
The courses or paths one might travel; the orientations one might follow from a given point.
Item 3
A material thing that can be seen and touched; something distinct from the surrounding environment.
+ 5 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 6 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free