Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
This passage is worth slow study because of how Marie Lu turns a numeric inventory into a piece of psychological prose. The opening sentence ('Anyone who's ever fallen on hard times will understand') invites the reader into a community — Lu is not asking us to feel sorry for Emika but to recognize her if we already know what she means. The catalog itself is doing two things at once: giving the reader the actual arithmetic of survival in New York City, and demonstrating what it feels like to live with that arithmetic running in the background of every thought. The final number — 13 — is set off as its own clause, deliberately small, so the reader can register the gap between what is needed and what exists. Lu refuses the convention of summarizing poverty with adjectives; she gives us the literal balance sheet because the literal balance sheet is the truth, and any softer version would be a kindness Emika has not been given. This is one of the most honest passages about economic precarity in contemporary YA fiction, and it works because Lu lets the numbers speak.
Anyone who's ever fallen on hard times will understand the nearly constant stream of numbers that run through my mind. A month's rent and the worst apartment in New York: 1,150. A month's food: 180. E...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Summarize the chapter in no more than five sentences, then identify what the chapter is fundamentally inquiring INTO — not what happens, but what philosophical, technological, or social question it asks the reader to consider — and justify your reading.
Discussion Questions
- Marie Lu opens her novel with a chapter that does the unusual work of being simultaneously a chase scene, an economic portrait, a piece of world-building, and an introduction to a complex protagonist. Most chapters do one of these things at a time. Lu does all four. Analyze the craft architecture that makes this density possible. What is Lu willing to leave out? What does she trust her reader to supply?
- The chapter contains a precise economic catalog ($1,150 rent, $180 food, $150 utilities, $3,450 unpaid rent, $6,000 credit card debt, $13 in the bank). This is the exact arithmetic of urban poverty for a young person in late-2010s America — and Lu has chosen to make it the chapter's emotional center. Is Lu making a serious argument about the structural conditions of contemporary American life, or is she using the arithmetic as a piece of dramatic stage-setting? And does the answer depend on whether we evaluate YA fiction by the standards of literary realism or by the standards of genre adventure?
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary Builder
Item 1
the structural condition of living without economic security — distinct from temporary financial trouble in that no single windfall can fix it; the term has been central to twenty-first-century discussions of labor, housing, and adolescent economic life
Item 2
an economic structure in which workers take short-term jobs without benefits, protections, or stability — the structure Emika is participating in as a freelance bounty hunter, and a structure that has been thoroughly critiqued by labor economists since 2010
Item 3
the belief that technological progress will solve human problems — a worldview that the contemporary tech industry has actively cultivated, and which YA fiction about technology often reproduces uncritically
+ 3 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 7 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free