Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
Burnett places two diagnostic sentences on either side of Ben's recognition: the gnarled-hand gesture that precedes speech, and the narrator's open judgment 'ignorant' and 'tactless' that immediately precedes the hoarse false interrogation. The passage models how rumor enters Colin's body — it arrives in a voice shaken by genuine recognition of his mother's eyes AND carrying the exact false content that has constituted him in the servants' imagination. Burnett refuses to let us take only the sympathetic half.
Ben Weatherstaff put his gnarled hand up and passed it over his eyes and over his forehead and then he did answer in a queer shaky voice. 'Who tha' art?' he said. 'Aye, that I do — wi' tha' mother's e...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Retell Chapter 21 as a three-movement sonata. Movement one: paradisal ingress — Colin's first afternoon under the plum-tree canopy, Dickon's sympathetic pedagogy, tea on the grass, the near-miss of the dead tree; movement two: intrusion — Ben Weatherstaff's indignant face at the top of the wall and his harangue of Mary; movement three: recognition and threshold-crossing — Colin's spellbound listening, his imperious command to Dickon, his confrontation with Ben, the rumor exposed, and the catastrophic standing. Attend to how Burnett's opening meditation on moments of cosmic certainty frames the whole.
Discussion Questions
- Burnett opens Chapter 21 with a philosophical proem on the rare moments when one is 'only now and then quite sure one is going to live forever and ever,' cataloguing them (tender solemn dawn, gold-stilled wood at sunset, immense quiet of dark blue night, far-off music, a look in someone's eyes). Argue for the specific function of this proem in a children's novel. What register does it establish, what expectations does it create, and why does Burnett risk the density of a contemplative opening at the start of a chapter about a disabled boy standing up for the first time at Misselthwaite?
- Burnett stages dramatic irony around the dead tree — Mary and Dickon know it is the tree where Mrs. Craven fell; Colin does not; the reader does. Develop a sustained argument about the moral function of irony in this scene. Is Burnett using irony merely for narrative tension, or is she inducting the reader into the specific ethical posture of Mary-and-Dickon — silent protection of the living child from the story his absent father could not bear? Argue for or against the claim that this is irony used as a moral pedagogy.
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary Builder
Item 1
Delivered a lengthy, forceful, often scolding address; Ben Weatherstaff harangued Mary from atop his ladder as a buttermilk-faced young besom who asked too many questions
Item 2
Rough, knotted, and twisted — characteristic of old trees or laborer's hands; Ben Weatherstaff raises his gnarled hand to his forehead before he can bring himself to answer the Rajah's demand
Item 3
Immobilized by fascination, as though held by an enchantment; Colin sits up and listens to Ben's torrent of angry words as if he were spellbound, unable to speak or move until the harangue finishes
+ 3 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 7 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free