Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
When the Socs file silently into the lot, Darry steps forward to start the rumble — and he comes face to face with Paul Holden, who used to be 'the best halfback on Darry's football team' and his close friend. The narration here is the most psychologically dense paragraph in the chapter: Pony is reading Paul's expression, then reading Darry's reaction to Paul's expression, then naming what no one else in the lot can see. Hinton lets the reader stand inside the older brother's shame. The fight has not started yet; the real wound has.
He was looking at Darry with an expression I couldn't quite place, but disliked. Contempt? Pity? Hate? All three? Why? Because Darry was standing there representing all of us, and maybe Paul felt only...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Narrate Chapter 9 in your own words. Cover: pre-rumble dinner, Pony's secret aspirin, the gang's tumbling in the yard, the catalog of motives ('fun, hatred, pride, conformity'), the walk to the lot, Tim Shepard and the Brumly boys, the silent arrival of the Socs, the Darry–Paul confrontation, the rumble, Dally's arrival with Two-Bit's switchblade, the police-escort drive, Dally's 'get tough' monologue, and Johnny's death.
Discussion Questions
- Pony names his friends' reasons for fighting in a single rapid line — 'Soda for fun, Steve for hatred, Darry for pride, Two-Bit for conformity' — and then leaves his own slot empty. How does Hinton use this list-and-silence structure to mark Pony's break with the gang's logic, and why does the empty slot do more work than any reason he could have given?
- Darry steps forward to fight Paul Holden — once his football teammate — under a streetlight while Pony reads 'contempt, pity, hate' in Paul's eyes. Where does the chapter locate the wound: in the two men, or in the class system that separated them? What evidence does Hinton give for her answer?
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary
Item 1
The feeling that someone or something is beneath one's notice or respect; scorn that does not even bother with anger
Item 2
Sorrow felt for another's suffering, often mixed with a sense of distance — the pitied person becomes a problem rather than a peer
Item 3
Resentful longing for what someone else has — here, Pony's word for Darry's reaction to Paul's college life
+ 5 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 6 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free