The Complete Tales and Poems of Edgar Allan Poe - Chapter 17

Study guide for Adult / College

Preview

Discussion Questions

Narration Prompt

Retell this chapter in sequence: how the schooner forces its way south through cracking ice into open water; how, past the Antarctic circle, the air and sea grow milder against expectation; how the crew loses Peter Vredenburgh overboard and passes a colossal iceberg; how a giant white bear storms the boat until Dirk Peters kills it with one stroke; how the crew lands on Bennet's Isle and finds a carved prow; and how, with fuel low and scurvy spreading, Captain Guy resolves to turn back while the narrator urges him onward, later confessing that 'bloody events' followed from his advice. Mark the moment the chapter's wonder is most shadowed by its cost, and ask why Poe places it there.

Discussion Questions

  1. Past the Antarctic circle the sea grows milder and opens, reversing every ordinary expectation about the pole. What might that reversal lead the crew to conclude about what lies ahead, and why should a careful reader treat that conclusion with caution? Use details from the chapter.
  2. The narrator presses Captain Guy onward against low fuel and spreading scurvy, then confesses that 'bloody events' followed from his advice. How should we weigh his ambition against the commander's caution, and why is that judgment genuinely hard? Use details from the chapter.

+ 2 more questions in the complete study guide

Critical Thinking

+ 7 more questions in the complete study guide

Get the complete study guide — free

Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.

Sign up free