Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
This is the chapter's third warning ignored — after the teacher's daily warnings and the Fairy's quoted warning in Chapter 26, the old Crab now climbs out of the sea to deliver the same message ('misfortune is sure to happen'), and Pinocchio answers with mockery. Collodi gives the Crab a comic voice (a trombone with a cold) but a serious office: he is the chapter's chorus, the wisdom-figure ignored. The narrator's intervention — 'Poor Crab! It was as if he had spoken to the wind' — adds a note of pathos that the chapter then earns with Eugene's injury two paragraphs later. The passage carries five of this lesson's vocabulary words (combat, trombone, misfortune, scoundrel, impolitely) and rewards careful imitation of its sentence rhythms.
Meanwhile the combat grew fiercer until a big old Crab came out of the water and, slowly walking up the beach, cried with the voice of a trombone that has caught a cold, "Stop it! stop it! These battl...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Reconstruct this chapter as four movements: the boys' confession that the dogfish was a trick to make Pinocchio skip school; the brawl on the beach culminating in Eugene's injury by Pinocchio's own arithmetic book; the policemen's arrest; and Pinocchio's escape with his hat between his teeth, fleeing the bloodhound through a cloud of dust.
Discussion Questions
- Examine the boys' confession of motive: 'Because we wanted you to lose a day at school... the scholars who study are always compared with those who do not; and we do not like it.' What does this admission reveal about envy as the chapter's quiet diagnosis of why Pinocchio was lured to the beach in the first place? How is envy different from simple laziness, and why is envy more dangerous to a friend?
- The chapter contains a third warning — the old Crab — after the teacher's daily warnings and the Fairy's quoted warning in Chapter 26. Collodi seems to be building a structure of repeated wisdom-figures whom Pinocchio will not hear. What does this triadic structure (teacher, Fairy, Crab) suggest about the chapter's view of how warnings actually function in moral life — and what is gained by giving the third warning a voice as comic as a trombone with a cold?
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary Builder
Item 1
Devoted to study; given over to learning with seriousness — the quality the wicked boys complain Pinocchio has 'too' much of.
Item 2
An armed or hand-to-hand struggle; the elevated word the narrator chooses to dignify what is, in fact, a schoolyard brawl.
Item 3
A long brass instrument with a sliding tube; used here in a comic simile for the Crab's voice — 'a trombone that has caught a cold.'
+ 5 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 6 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free