Summer of the Monkeys — Chapter 17

Narration Prompt

Narrate Chapter 17 as a single dramatic action in three structural movements, attending to how Rawls synchronizes interior reversal with exterior landscape. Movement one (the moral trap): Grandpa, with pedagogical calculation, places a crippled paint mare beside a healthy roan gelding, then refuses to choose for Jay Berry and drops parabolic hints — 'a lot of cripples could be helped if someone would just take the time,' 'a fellow can want something so bad he will overlook things that are more important' — while the mare petitions the boy with her head and Rowdy renders his silent canine vote. Movement two (the peripeteia): on the country road home, Daisy's favorite hymn from her hillside playhouse and the raw wound on the mare's fetlock fuse 'like a bolt of lightning,' Jay Berry drops the halter rope, buries his face in his arms on a rock beside the road, and the long walk back to the store becomes the chapter's via dolorosa — Papa watching silently from his plow, his hat held still. Movement three (the kenotic return): the silent exchange on the porch, Grandpa's 'O ye of little faith' self-indictment against the student's triumph, Grandma's already-prepared cloth sack of savings, Mama's grayish-white silence and whispered doxology that addresses the Lord before her son, and Papa's first-ever handshake — the private agrarian rite of initiation performed after mother and sister have left the kitchen to pack.

Discussion Questions

1. Grandpa's 'O ye of little faith' — the chapter's only explicit biblical quotation — is spoken against himself at the moment of Jay Berry's moral triumph. The success of the parable does not exonerate the arranger. Consider the paradox theologically and pedagogically: faith in a method can coexist with lack of faith in a particular person, and the latter alone can shame even the author of a successful lesson. How does this costly humility change our understanding of Grandpa as a character, of the chapter's theology, and of what Rawls is asking adult readers to recognize in their own teaching of the young?
2. The novel's plot-climax (Chapter 16: monkeys caught, bounty paid) and moral-climax (Chapter 17: pony renounced) are deliberately misaligned, and the novel continues into Chapters 18-19. Analyze what this structural misalignment reveals about Rawls's theory of the novel as a form. If the monkeys were the subject, the book would end with their capture; if the sacrifice were the subject, the book would be titled for it. What is the novel about, if it refuses both closures?

+ 2 more questions in the complete study guide