Summer of the Monkeys — Chapter 17

About This Passage

Rawls places the novel's most explicit theological utterance in the mouth of the most taciturn character, at the moment of the most complete moral reversal. 'O ye of little faith' — a Christological rebuke from the Gospels (Matthew 8:26, 14:31, 16:8) spoken by Jesus to disciples who have doubted in moments of crisis — is used here by Grandpa against himself. The rhetorical move is quietly astonishing: the wise elder, who engineered the entire parable of the crippled pony, confesses that he was not sure his own method would work. He lacked faith in Jay Berry, and now — at the moment of the boy's moral triumph — that lack of faith is what shames him. Notice the craftsmanship: Grandpa hands back the money BEFORE he speaks (restitution precedes speech); his voice 'quivered with emotion' (the stoic rural elder breaks); and the scripture is not preached but invoked sideways, as though Grandpa cannot quite say it in his own words. Rawls achieves a triple effect — an explicit biblical anchor for the novel's moral universe, a portrait of the teacher's humility before the student's virtue, and a refusal of heroic closure: even the hero of the parable doubts himself at the moment of the parable's success.

Narration Prompt

Retell Chapter 17 attending to its three structural movements and their theological register. Movement one (the moral trap): Grandpa arranges the two-pony choice with calculated indirection — the healthy roan next to the crippled paint — and drops parabolic hints ('a lot of cripples could be helped if someone would just take the time') while refusing to name the lesson. Movement two (the peripeteia): on the walk home, Daisy's hymn from the hillside and the raw wound on the pony's fetlock fuse into a simultaneous recognition that strikes 'like a bolt of lightning,' Jay Berry drops the halter rope, and the long walk back becomes the chapter's via dolorosa. Movement three (the kenotic return): the silent exchange on the porch, Grandpa's 'O ye of little faith' self-indictment, Grandma's already-prepared sack, Mama's grayish-white silence and whispered doxology to the Lord, and Papa's first-ever handshake — the private agrarian rite of initiation conducted in the kitchen after mother and sister have left the room.

Discussion Questions

1. Rawls structures Grandpa's pedagogy as a Socratic-parabolic engineering of circumstance: the crippled pony, the healthy pony, the refusal to choose, the repeated remarks about 'cripples,' and the warning that 'a fellow can want something so bad he will overlook things that are more important.' Analyze what this method presupposes about the nature of moral knowledge. Is moral knowledge, in Rawls's vision, a matter of propositional assent (learning what is true and agreeing to it), or a matter of acquired perception (learning to SEE what is true)? What are the stakes of each model for how literature and education should work?
2. Grandpa's 'O ye of little faith' self-indictment at the moment of Jay Berry's moral triumph presents a paradox: the teacher feels shame precisely when the lesson has succeeded. Consider the theological and psychological dimensions of this paradox. Why does the success of the parable not exonerate the teacher? What does this tell us about the difference between faith in a method and faith in a person — and about the costly character of teaching the young?

+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide