Prince Caspian — Chapter 9

Narration Prompt

Summarize the chapter's argument or narrative arc, then identify the central tension and evaluate whether the author handles it honestly.

Discussion Questions

1. Lewis constructs a scene in which genuine perception (Lucy sees Aslan) and reasonable doubt (the others see nothing) coexist without either being epistemologically irresponsible. Evaluate whether Lewis has achieved a genuine philosophical insight about the irreducibly personal nature of certain kinds of knowledge, or whether he has merely constructed a narrative that validates private experience by authorial fiat — using his control of the story to guarantee that the visionary is right.
2. Edmund's support for Lucy rests on a form of knowledge that Alvin Plantinga might call 'properly basic' — grounded not in evidence for Lucy's current claim but in Edmund's direct experience of a relevantly similar past event. Evaluate Edmund's belief-formation process. Is it rational, or is it merely lucky? Does the distinction matter if the result is the same?

+ 2 more questions in the complete study guide