Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
This is Papa's explanation to Annemarie of why Ellen is sleeping over and why Mr. and Mrs. Rosen are gone. Lois Lowry has Papa make a striking move at the end: he stacks four 'we don't know' clauses — they don't know where, why, what 'relocation' means — and then pivots on a single 'we only know.' The pathfinder copying this passage should attend to the architecture of the sentence. Papa is admitting epistemic limits with unusual honesty (a parent who pretends to know everything would say less true things). And then he commits the family to action without those limits being lifted. The chapter is teaching the reader that the moral demand for help does not wait for full information. 'It is wrong, and it is dangerous, and we must help' is the chapter's hinge — and one of the moral hinges of the entire book.
"This morning, at the synagogue, the rabbi told his congregation that the Nazis have taken the synagogue lists of all the Jews. Where they live, what their names are. Of course the Rosens were on that...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Retell chapter four with attention to its structural movement. The chapter opens domestic and almost playful: Annemarie and Ellen with paper dolls, Kirsti's fish-skin shoes, Ellen's offer to ink them black. Then it slides historical: Tivoli, the August 'birthday fireworks' that were really the scuttled Danish fleet, Mama's protective renaming and Papa's single-word answer 'How proud.' Then domestic again, but tighter: Mrs. Rosen at the door (not entering), Mama announcing the 'nice surprise,' the worried dinner, Kirsti sent to bed with a story of a king. Then the chapter's confrontation: Papa's explanation of the synagogue list, the Rosens' hidden, the pretend-sister plan, and the closing 'three daughters' embrace.
Discussion Questions
- Examine the architecture of Papa's explanation: four 'we don't know' clauses followed by a single 'we only know... we must help.' Why does Lois Lowry have Papa stack uncertainty before the moral commitment? What is the chapter teaching the reader about the relationship between full information and the duty to act?
- Mama returns from her hallway conversation with Mrs. Rosen and announces 'a nice surprise' in a cheerful voice — even though, the narrator says, 'her face was worried.' Annemarie immediately objects, in dismay, because she has noticed the mismatch. What does this small sequence tell you about Mama, and about how Annemarie has been changing as a reader of the adults around her?
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary Builder
Item 1
a group of people gathered together for religious worship, especially in a synagogue or church
Item 2
the building in which Jewish people assemble for worship and religious study
Item 3
a Jewish religious teacher and spiritual leader of a congregation
+ 5 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 6 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free