Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
Miss Franny's whispered claim is one of the book's most direct political statements, and it is worth studying because it manages to be polemical without being preachy. Notice that DiCamillo has Miss Franny WHISPER the claim. The whisper is doing crucial work — it tells us that this is a private, almost confessional truth, not a public sermon. A whispered political claim feels earned in a way a shouted one would not. Notice also the structure: a sweeping generalization ('always'), an explanation ('always looking for a reason'), an evaluation ('the saddest thing'), and a diagnosis ('the abiding notion'). The four moves take Miss Franny from observation to philosophy in a single breath. The phrase 'abiding notion' is the load-bearing phrase — it identifies the false belief as something that lives in the body, not in the mind. Beliefs that abide are beliefs no argument can dislodge. The passage teaches a writer how to deliver a strong claim through a specific voice and a specific physical gesture (the whisper), and how to use a small word like 'abiding' to mark the depth of an idea.
Men and boys always want to fight, she whispered. They are always looking for a reason to go to war. It's the saddest thing. They have this abiding notion that war is fun, and no history lesson will c...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Retell Miss Franny's bear story. Then identify the moment when the war story stops being a piece of family history and starts being a warning to the children listening. What signal does DiCamillo give us?
Discussion Questions
- DiCamillo has Miss Franny WHISPER her claim that 'men and boys always want to fight.' The whisper is an unusual choice for a strong political statement. Why a whisper? What does the whisper signal about the kind of truth-telling Miss Franny is doing?
- Litmus enlisted at fourteen by lying about his age. The chapter does not condemn the lie. Is this an oversight, a moral judgment that war-eagerness in young men is its own punishment, or a refusal to make Litmus's lie the subject of moral evaluation when the larger moral problem is the war itself?
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary Builder
Item 1
lasting, settled, not subject to dislodgement by reason — a feeling or belief that has become part of how a person lives, not just what they think
Item 2
engaged in argument or controversy, especially on a political or moral question — sometimes a critical word, but not always
Item 3
the telling of what one has witnessed or what has been passed down through witness, often as a way of preserving truth that would otherwise be lost
+ 5 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 6 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free