Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
This sentence is one of the most devastatingly compressed pieces of writing in the book. In a single long compound sentence, DiCamillo accomplishes a major developmental shift in Opal: for the first time, Opal imagines herself as the object of her mother's experience rather than as the subject of her own. The sentence has two parts. The first half ('I wondered if my mama... had a tree full of bottles') extends Gloria's bottle tree out into the world — the question becomes whether Opal's mother has her own version of the same discipline of remembered wrongs. The second half ('and I wondered if I was a ghost to her') reverses the perspective: Opal now imagines being someone else's haunting memory. Notice the parallelism: 'a ghost to her the same way she sometimes seemed like a ghost to me.' The structure forces the reader to see that haunting goes both ways. A child who has been haunted by an absent mother is now imagining herself as the haunting presence in the mother's life. This is the development of empathy — not as feeling FOR another person but as imagining oneself FROM another person's point of view. Copying this sentence teaches a writer how to render a developmental shift without ever announcing that the shift is happening. The reader who follows the sentence carefully will feel Opal grow.
I wondered if my mama, wherever she was, had a tree full of bottles, and I wondered if I was a ghost to her the same way she sometimes seemed like a ghost to me.
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Summarize the chapter in no more than four sentences. Then identify the central question the chapter is inquiring into beneath its surface plot, and defend your reading.
Discussion Questions
- Gloria's central principle — 'judge them by what they are doing now' — is delivered in a single sentence and immediately applied to a specific person (Otis). DiCamillo refuses to leave the principle abstract. Analyze this craft choice. Why is the immediate application essential, and what would change if Gloria had delivered the principle without the application?
- Gloria's bottle tree functions as memorial, discipline, confession, and warning all at once. This is a remarkably dense symbolic structure for a children's book. Is DiCamillo making a claim that real symbols should always carry multiple functions, or is she using the bottle tree to demonstrate that children's literature can carry the same density as adult fiction when it is written by a serious enough writer?
+ 2 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary Builder
Item 1
the moment in fiction or in life when a character imagines themselves from another person's point of view rather than from their own — often the moment when empathy becomes possible
Item 2
fitted into a smaller space than the content would normally require — in writing, the discipline of saying much in few words
Item 3
a tree decorated with colored glass bottles, originally a West African folk practice brought to the American South, believed to catch evil spirits in the glass
+ 3 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 7 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free