Preview
Copywork
About This Passage
Study how Orwell turns a clerk's small forgery into a statement about the nature of truth. The blunt first sentence, 'was now a fact,' treats an invention as settled reality. The strange middle observation, that one can 'create dead men but not living ones,' exposes the Party's eerie power: it cannot make a real person breathe, but it can write a fictional one into the historical record. The long final sentence delivers the chilling conclusion, that once the forgery is forgotten, the made-up Ogilvy will rest on exactly the same evidence as figures we accept as real history. Orwell's point is that a fact with no surviving proof is only as true as the records say.
Comrade Ogilvy, unimagined an hour ago, was now a fact. It struck him as curious that you could create dead men but not living ones. Comrade Ogilvy, who had never existed in the present, now existed i...
Full copywork activity with handwriting lines available in the complete study guide.
Discussion Questions
Narration Prompt
Retell this chapter in order: Winston goes to his job at the Ministry of Truth, where his work is to 'rectify' old newspapers so the past always matches what the Party says today; he drops the originals into a memory hole to be burned, so all of history becomes a palimpsest rewritten with no proof left; he reflects on coworkers, including a woman who deletes erased people though her own husband was vaporised, and on how a disgraced official, Withers, has become an unperson; for his main job he replaces Withers's mention by inventing a heroic but entirely fictional Comrade Ogilvy, and reflects that an invented man can become as 'real' in the records as any figure from history. When you reach Winston's reflection on creating Comrade Ogilvy, slow down and weigh what it means that a forgery can become a fact.
Discussion Questions
- Winston's entire job at the Ministry of Truth is to 'rectify' old records so the past always agrees with the Party's present. What does it reveal about this society that altering the past is steady, organized, full-time work, and why? Support your reading with the text.
- Winston is skilled at this work and takes his greatest pleasure in the hardest forgeries, even though the job is to replace truth with lies. Do you read Winston here mainly as a victim trapped by the system, or as someone who shares real responsibility for the lying? Defend one reading with evidence from the chapter, and explain why it fits the text better than the other.
+ 3 more questions in the complete study guide
Vocabulary
Item 1
The act of deliberately altering something to make it false; once the deed is done, no proof remains that any falsification of the records ever took place.
Item 2
The making up of something untrue; handing the job to a committee would be to admit openly that an act of fabrication, the inventing of lies, was taking place.
Item 3
Replaced by a newer version and made out of date; clerks track down every document that has been superseded so the old copies can be destroyed.
+ 5 more vocabulary words in the complete study guide
Critical Thinking
+ 6 more questions in the complete study guide
Get the complete study guide — free
Sign up and get your first book with every chapter included. Copywork, discussion questions, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Sign up free